Legal Team for Clare Bronfman Files Reply Brief in Appeal of NXIVM Case; Highlights Extraordinarily Harsh Sentence in Punishment for a Crime Court Admits Bronfman Did Not Commit | The Fall Of NXIVM
Skip to content
  • Home
  • The Book
  • About
    • Toni Natalie
    • Chet Hardin
  • The Coverage
  • Contact

The Fall of NXIVM

  • Home
  • The Book
  • About
    • Toni Natalie
    • Chet Hardin
  • The Coverage
  • Contact

The Coverage Archives

A library archiving NXIVM related coverage throughout the years.

Categories: Clare Bronfman · DOS · Eastern District · Keith Raniere

Legal Team for Clare Bronfman Files Reply Brief in Appeal of NXIVM Case; Highlights Extraordinarily Harsh Sentence in Punishment for a Crime Court Admits Bronfman Did Not Commit

Published by CISION PR Newswire on January 31, 2022

By Ronald Sullivan Law, PLLC

Credit: CISION PR Newswire

NEW YORK, Jan. 31, 2022 /PRNewswire/ — In a reply brief filed last week by the legal team of Clare Bronfman, attorneys for the Seagram’s heiress argued that the district court’s extraordinarily harsh 81-month sentence was handed down in error, particularly as the court punished her on the basis of activities it explicitly admitted she did not participate in and knew nothing about.

While Bronfman was an active member of NXIVM and a proponent of its teachings, like tens of thousands of others around the world, the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York sentenced her to 81 months in prison based on her purported linkages to DOS—a secret organization whose existence was known only to the small group comprising its membership. As the District Court itself noted, “Ms. Bronfman vigorously disputes the proposition that she was aware of either DOS or any sex trafficking…. She vigorously disputes the proposition that she knowingly funded DOS or sex trafficking activity. I agree with Ms. Bronfman that the available evidence does not establish that she was aware of DOS prior to June 2017 or that she directly or knowingly funded DOS or other sex trafficking activities.”

Still, DOS was “relevant context for my analysis of the appropriate sentence for Ms. Bronfman,” the court said.

“The sentence that Ms. Bronfman received was clearly for crimes she did not commit and was not aware of, as evidenced by the court’s own statements and reasoning,” said Ronald S. Sullivan Jr., an attorney for Ms. Bronfman. “By the court’s own admission, she found out about DOS at the same time the rest of the world did.”

Bronfman pleaded guilty to two charges related to identity theft and immigration fraud, yet the court amassed a litany of attempts to bring DOS into the case

Click here for original

Post navigation

Previous PostPigeon sentencing in political corruption case postponed til May
Next PostFrank Parlato summonsed in federal court for Western District of New York for a possible bail violation; also, unnamed “parties” in his case are “re-engaging in plea negotiations”

    Categories

    • Allison Mack (10)
    • Andrew Cuomo (1)
    • Anthony Ames (1)
    • Barbara Bouchey (10)
    • Barbara Jeske (1)
    • Brandon Porter (1)
    • Brendan Lyons (1)
    • Catherine Oxenberg (4)
    • Chet Hardin (20)
    • Christine Marie (1)
    • Clare Bronfman (29)
    • Consumers' Buyline (11)
    • DA John Flynn (1)
    • Dalai Lama (2)
    • Damon Brink (2)
    • Danielle Roberts (2)
    • David Soares (7)
    • Dennis Yusko (2)
    • DOS (3)
    • Eastern District (12)
    • Edgar Bronfman (4)
    • Emiliano Salinas (2)
    • Executive Success Programs (15)
    • Frank Parlato (39)
    • Frank Parlato Jr. (19)
    • Frank Report (39)
    • G. Steven Pigeon (1)
    • Gina Hutchinson (1)
    • Gina Melita (1)
    • Heidi Hutchinson (1)
    • Hillary Clinton (3)
    • Holly Trexler (1)
    • India Oxenberg (1)
    • Interfor (6)
    • Jack Casey (3)
    • James Odato (4)
    • Jennifer Kobelt (1)
    • Joe Bruno (4)
    • John Tighe (2)
    • Joseph O'Hara (16)
    • Joseph Tully (1)
    • Juval Aviv (8)
    • Karen Unterenrier (2)
    • Keith Raniere (71)
    • Kristin Keeffe (16)
    • Kristin Kreuk (2)
    • Kristin Snyder (7)
    • Lauren Salzman (4)
    • LeBaron (3)
    • Mark Vicente (4)
    • Mexico (6)
    • Michael Sutton (2)
    • Moria Kim Penza (2)
    • Nancy Salzman (35)
    • Nicki Clyne (6)
    • NXIVM (95)
    • O'Connell & Aronowitz (2)
    • Pam Cafritz (8)
    • Pamela A Nichols (2)
    • Paul A. Grenga (2)
    • Rex Smith (1)
    • Richard Mays (4)
    • Rick Ross (26)
    • Rodger Stone (7)
    • Sally Brink (1)
    • Sara Bronfman (25)
    • Sarah Edmondson (4)
    • Senior U.S. District Judge Nicholas Garaufis (3)
    • Soukaina Mehdaoui (1)
    • Steve Rombom (1)
    • Steven Pigeon (13)
    • Suneel Chakravorty (1)
    • Susan Dones (7)
    • Suzanna Andrews (1)
    • Svetlana Kotlin (1)
    • The Niagara Reporter (1)
    • The Program (14)
    • Times Union (2)
    • Toni Natalie (49)
    • Western District of New York (1)
    • Yuri Plyam (3)

    Publications

    • Times Union (39)
    • The Buffalo News (11)
    • New York Post (7)
    • Niagara Falls Reporter (5)
    • Reddit (5)
    • Niagara Gazette (4)
    • Metroland (3)
    • The Sanctuary for Independent Media (2)
    • Pink Shade With Erin Martin (2)
    • Kernwatch (2)
    • New York TImes (2)
    • Daily Mail (2)
    • Democrat & Chronicle (2)
    • Vanity Fair (2)
    • Oxygen - True Crime (2)
    • THE CUT (1)
    • Fox News (1)
    • ABC 13 WHAM (1)
    • CISION PR Newswire (1)
    • gothamist (1)
    • Seven Days (1)
    • BBC (1)
    • Courthouse News (1)
    • Poynter (1)
    • Spectrum News (1)
    • ET (1)
    • ELLE (1)
    • House of Mystery Radio Show NBC News Radio (1)
    • Radar Online (1)
    • WAMC (1)
    • Roberta Glass True Crime Report (1)
    • Matt D'Elia Is Confused (1)
    • The Collaborative (1)
    • Time (1)
    • PREVAIL by Greg Olear (1)
    • Parallax Views w/ J.G. Michael (1)
    • Telegram (1)
    • Vice (1)
    • Toronto Star (1)
    • Cult Education Institute (1)
    • Forbes (1)
    • New York Mag - Intelligencer (1)
    • The Village Voice (1)
    • Chicago Tribune (1)
    • Artvoice (1)
    • LittleSis.org (1)
    • SwamiVivekananda.net (1)
    • Internet Archive (1)
    • Casetext (1)
    • Chicago Sun-Times (1)
    • Slate (1)
    • Jezebel (1)
    • MTV News (1)
    • Columbia Journal Review (1)
    • Melville House (1)
    • The Nation (1)
    • Man Making (1)
    • WNYT (1)
    • Syracuse.com (1)
    • New York Daily News (1)
    • Page Six (1)
    • NYup.com (1)
    • Wikipedia (1)

    Bylines

    • Dennis Yusko (16)
    • Robert Gavin (11)
    • James M. Odato (6)
    • Chet Hardin (5)
    • Jennifer Gish (4)
    • Emily Saul (4)
    • incorruptible_bk (4)
    • James Odato (3)
    • Jon Campbell (3)
    • Rick Pfeiffer (3)
    • Gina Tron (2)
    • Melissa Roberto (2)
    • Andrew Keshner (2)
    • Dan Herbeck (2)
    • Aaron Besecker (2)
    • Frank Parlato Jr. (2)
    • Frank Parlato (2)
    • Erin Martin (2)
    • Andrew Denney (2)
    • Chris Spargo (2)
    • Kristen Hare (1)
    • Phil Fairbanks (1)
    • Nick Rummell (1)
    • Reuven Fenton (1)
    • Lia Eustachewich (1)
    • Jasmine Aguilera (1)
    • Sarah Berman (1)
    • Leon Krauze (1)
    • Sarah Trefethen (1)
    • The Tribune News Services (1)
    • Colin Moynihan (1)
    • Joe Donahue (1)
    • Jaclyn Cangro (1)
    • Mike Browne (1)
    • Ronald Sullivan Law, PLLC (1)
    • Chris Churchill (1)
    • Patrick Lakamp (1)
    • Maki Becker (1)
    • Paul Heintz (1)
    • Greg Olear (1)
    • Kevin O'Toole (1)
    • The Sanctuary for Independent Media (1)
    • Alan Warren (1)
    • Stacy Lambe (1)
    • Katie Heaney (1)
    • Rose Minutaglio (1)
    • J.G. Michael (1)
    • Kate Sheehy (1)
    • David Howard King (1)
    • Matt D'Elia (1)
    • Ati Abdo MacDonald (1)
    • Roberta Glass (1)
    • Ebony Bowden (1)
    • Priscilla DeGregory (1)
    • William D. Cohan (1)
    • Geoff Herbert (1)
    • Andrew Rusiniak (1)
    • Rick Forgione (1)
    • Gail Franklin (1)
    • Nancy A. Fischer (1)
    • Michael Freedman (1)
    • John Hochman M.D. (1)
    • Lillian Boncore (1)
    • David Orenstein (1)
    • Michal Kuzma (1)
    • Gene Warner (1)
    • Intelligencer (1)
    • Stephanie Desmon (1)
    • Elizabeth O'Mara (1)
    • Robert J. MacCarthy (1)
    • Douglas Turner (1)
    • Charles Anzalone (1)
    • Carolyn Raeke (1)
    • Carl Allen (1)
    • Agnes Palazzetti (1)
    • James Heaney (1)
    • Jeane MacIntosh (1)
    • CHRIS THOMPSON (1)
    • Kumi Tucker (1)
    • Laura Kane (1)
    • Barry Meier (1)
    • Tony Farina (1)
    • Mark Sommer (1)
    • Sal Robinson (1)
    • Sara Morrison (1)
    • Max Evry (1)
    • Doug Barry (1)
    • Michael Calleri (1)
    • Niagara Falls Reporter (1)
    • Thomason Dialog (1)
    • Lenny Palumbo (1)
    • William F. Savno, Esq. (1)
    • Bernard Schenkler, Esq. (1)
    • Joseph J. O'Hara (1)
    • Suzanna Andrews (1)
    • Kevin Connor (1)
    • Geoff Kelly (1)
    • Mike I Niman (1)
    • Steve Schmadeke (1)
    • Thomas J. Prohaska (1)

Tell us your story

Do you have a story to share about Keith Raniere, NXIVM, DOS, Consumers' Buyline Inc, or National Health Network? Contact us here. This is confidential. Your information will not be shared without your permission.

About the authors

Toni Natalie spent eight years with Keith Raniere, as his girlfriend and business partner. She watched as he  transformed himself from multi-level marketing guru into the cult leader known as Vanguard. When Toni finally left him, he threatened her: “I will see you dead or in jail.” He was half right.

Chet Hardin is the only journalist to play a midnight game of volleyball with actress Allison Mack, Seagram heiress Clare Bronfman, and the now-notorious Keith Raniere.

Contact details

Toni Natalie
[email protected]

Chet Hardin
(719) 419-2411
[email protected]

Follow on Twitter: @thefallofnxivm

Buy The Program

© The Fall of NXIVM • 2017 to 2022